Not overly familiar with these but will vote for Jack Lemmon

Red Buttons

Jack Lemmon. Classic comedy, class act. Anyone who hasn't seen the Apartment should do themselves a favor and check it out.

Jack Lemmon

I can't vote for Lemmon because I don't consider him a comedian. This is the best comedian tournament. Jack Lemmon is one of the most talented actors to ever grace the silver screen. Many of his roles are comic. But that doesn't, IMO, make him a comedian.

So I have to vote for Mr. Buttons.

5-4-0, Jack Lemmon edges out Red Buttons.

Round 1 Match 24



Janeane Garofalo

http://i9.photobucket.com/albums/a77...falo_may03.jpg






vs.




Richard Belzer

http://i439.photobucket.com/albums/q...hardBelzer.jpg






vs.




Buster Keaton

http://i266.photobucket.com/albums/i...001_keaton.gif






First to 5 wins.

Really like both Garofolo & Belzer- but Keaton? A league of his own.

Janeane Garofalo

Buster Keaton...the legend of Celluloid Comedy.